Before my six-year-old daughter finished unwrapping her birthday gift from my in-laws, she hugged the little brown teddy bear with a huge smile. Then, without warning, she stiffened, pulled it away from herself, and quietly asked, “Mommy… what is wrong with its eye?” I took one look, and the color drained from my face. I didn’t panic. I took action instead. Three days later, the police were standing on my in-laws’ front porch.

Downstairs, I heard Marcus moving with practiced, silent efficiency. He was hiding in the adjacent formal dining room, shrouded in absolute darkness. He had left the dismantled, gutted chestnut bear in plain sight on the kitchen island, illuminated dramatically by a single, harsh pendant light.